My name is Jennifer and I am a vintage addict.
It's a dilemma that has been brought to my attention by the long cold winter and the impracticality of my vintage wardrobe. For the last 3 years, my modern wardrobe, full of clothes from high street stores like H&M and Topshop has slowly been depleted; given away to friends, charity shops or sold on ebay. I now have a wardrobe that I am proud of, full of amazing vintage finery, each item unique and not bought on a whim, (well, mostly) but pondered over, checked for fading and imperfections, and measurements checked...and checked again. A vintage wardrobe is an investment, a collection of dearly loved possessions that I know have a monetary worth and that I can one day sell on to someone else who will love them dearly.
![]() |
| My most treasured vintage posessions....that are impossibly painful |
However I have been recently alerted to the fact that I may have been too hasty in getting rid of my modern clothes. It has been rather cold in old Blighty, those of you in the far flung corners of the globe may have even (rather embarassingly for us) been alerted to the chaos that the Nation succumbed to when snow fell, (as it is likely to do) just before Christmas. Well I do like snow, but my suede 1940s shoes don't. I searched for boots and found vintage sheepskin ones that were very warm, but slightly ill fitting. Hmmm. My ridiculousy vintaged-addled brain just will not allow me to buy anything that doesn't look period enough, therefore for the sake of 'vintage' fashion I have been cold on more than one occasion. I have warm vintage coats, but they can be very expensive and sometimes no matter how many layers you put on under your dress, its not the same as being able to go to a shop full of clothes designed for the season and being able to pick something out in your size. Don't get me wrong, I do buy from the high street. For example, one of the girls caught on to the fact that Zara were selling some lovely vintage inspired knits and skirts this winter, so when the January sale started I made my way to Zara and invested in a lovely cardigan and 40s style skirt. Clarks, as usual have had some wonderful shoes in their Originals range, inspired by their own early designs.
![]() |
| Vintage Rain Protection Perfection |
Another area where I feel I would be warmer/possibly more comfortable, if I just felt more myself being a bit more un-vintage is the matter of stockings/tights. I feel weird if I don't have a seam running up the back of my leg, but there are days when I wish I didn't have to fiddle around with suspender belts and girdles. I hate black tights, and there is nothing worse than a pretty floral vintage dress ruined by a pair of heavy black tights. In the spring I may wear nude tights, but it still feels weird to me not to have a seam, and I have yet to find a good quality pair of nude seamed tights that will last for more than one wear.

Ok, so I sound like a vintage snob moaning about ridiculous self imposed restrictions, but it's just a frame of mind I have gotten myself in. Creating an authentic look has become my obsession. I know I am not alone in this. Some of my girlfriends have said the same thing. We were talking about the fact that we do perhaps have to open ourselves up to the fact that there are nice vintage inspired clothing out there, and we don't have to feel guilty if we buy it. Perhaps by living in our little vintage bubble we are actually missing out on nice clothing. There is of course something to be said for the practically of clothing that can be thrown in the washing machine. Thank goodness for reproduction clothing brands such as Heyday!, Freddies of Pinewood, Rocket Originals and Puttin' On The Ritz to name but a few, who have given us the best of both worlds, providing replicas of period clothing that can be washed to suit the practical modern day standards that we are used to. As wonderful as these clothing companies are, you have to pay for the privilege. The time, care and attention that goes into creating authentic reproduction clothing doesn't come cheap.
![]() |
| Beuatiful Repro Fleur dress from Heyday! |
So this is the vintage dilemma....am I just too vintage? I know that when Summer finally arrives my high vintage standards need not be lowered, as every vintage gal knows that Summer is the season when we can really be ourselves. The abundance of pretty vintage cotton frocks that are withering unloved in my wardrobe at the moment will finally be set free again, and along with vintage sandals and when it get it's really hot *gasp* no stockings/tights/or restrictive undergarments. But, for a change this Summer, I may just take a little peek at what the shops have to offer us vintage girls, as I may be missing out on some beautiful clothes, and maybe, just maybe I'll try and be a little less vintage......



Great post, and I totally feel your pain, although I personally still have plenty of modern wardrobe to deplete :)and have not been touched yet by the vintage undergarment "disease" to the same extent as more dedicate vintage lovers have. I'm sure that too will come to its peak in my life. But nevertheless, my husband has commented that I have become slightly fixate if not snobbish in my choices. But I still wore my non vintage boots this winter- bought about 3 years ago, and my Laura Ashley 40's inspired coat, without necessarily feeling guilty. What I feel is... sour...when I'm losing auctions on ebay when trying to buy the real stuff ...but my money just doesn't stretch enough. The 30's coat I missed out on a couple of months ago left a big deep wound. :) I'm sad like that, ya know. My time will come, I just wished it happened sooner, while I can still look decent in the stuff that is.
ReplyDeleteI’m exactly the same- being authentic means a lot to me and I try my very hardest to be true to my eras (with some exceptions). With this in mind I get very upset when people point out things that are wrong – it’s always the shoes- they think I should be looking tip top all the time!Because of these comments I hate to stray into anything other than vintage of vintage inspired just in case these people think I don’t have a clue when it comes ‘vintage’! I fret over the silliest things- just can’t help it- I’m in too deep with this vintage malarkey. Tups xxx (posting soon!)
ReplyDeleteI know what you mean, it's a scary world out there on the high street, I had to go into topshop the other day when my mother came to visit and I felt completely lost. I personally if I am going to buy something modern I opt for the charity shop, I've got some nice Zara knits and topshop shoes for under £5 and the fact thats its a little worn suits my comfort zone of wearing vintage!
ReplyDeleteBut on another note.....
I saw you in the Vintage Emporium where I work on Sunday, I didn't want to bother you though as you where enjoying tea and cake. I was making an awful mess as I usually work in the clothes shop but as we are having some floor fitted I tried my hands at being a barrister, hope you had a nice day and do pop buy the emporium again soon!
Harriett x
I have panicked moments when this happens to me: it's often too cold and snowy or wet and mushy outside here to imagine wearing a dress, stockings, and vintage shoes OR even some stylish wide legged vintage style trousers. Fact is, such things just don't jive with winter boots and parkas that truly keep one warm (at least here where I live). If you're allergic to wool, it gets even worse. I've slowly learned tricks to work around such issues. I'm lucky, in that most of the time when I am going out in public on weekends or evenings, we are going there by car, so as long as I layer a vintage coat over my dress (which I usually wear with some kind of cardigan) and definitely wear stockings of some type; I can carry my precious vintage shoes and wear my cute non-vintage waterproof boots to and from the venue & car. That being said, I've almost frozen to death on more than one occasion, just walking two blocks from art gallery to car, etc. The sad thing is, when I've gone to the mall to look at the mainstream shops for clothes, I get frustrated because the cute stuff is made of poor fabric, is poorly crafted, and usually too short in length for the likes of me. So, in the end, I've found myself more likely to go repro. whenever my vintage is just not going to cut it. I feel your pain, though!!
ReplyDeleteYou´re definitely not alone, that´s exactly how I feel in the ugly days of winter. But the sun is near, since this week I hear the birds singing in the morning :-) Hang in there, your vintage wardrobe is beautiful, no reason to chance it!
ReplyDeleteSusan
Those shoes are incredible!
ReplyDeleteSo glad I'm not alone in this ladies!!!
ReplyDeleteHarriett: Do come and say hi next time...if I spot you first I will! Its a regular hang out for me and the girls so I'm sure I'll be in there again soon.xxx
Unfortunately I face this dilemma every day: the nature of my job simply means that I would be uncomfortable and it would be impractical to dress 'for style' all the time. Luckily I'm more 60s-70s so stylish slacks/trousers/maxis are slightly easier to find... unlike mid-20th ladies, Summer can be a problem. Polyester is NOT great in July!
ReplyDeleteI must admit when some (none that I follow) vintage bloggers blithely talk about being 'ladylike' 100% of the time I grind my teeth (not least because 'ladylike' is not the same as feminine: it is intrinsically tied up in class- i.e. in those days it was aspirational not to have to work, hence 'being a lady' is not the same as 'being feminine'. Unless all vintage means is wearing pwetty dwesses and comwaining that girlies now are mean and wuff. I have much more admiration for feminine women who wore slacks and raised families and worked- but with style). Part of my interest in vintage lies in real lives and real histories: I never want to base my look on a fashion plate. Whether it's Ladgirls, Teddy Boys, Hippies or Reggea, I've always been fascinated by what regular folk wore.
I love a mixture of vintage and modern, so I have the best of both worlds... but I do love your look and your style and think that perhaps you suffer to be that stylish. It must be nice to know you look so glam all of the time though. Also, you never come across like a vintage snob, if that's any consolation.
ReplyDeleteI guess that is what they call suffering for your art!
ReplyDeleteAs a dedicated shopper I say don't be so hard on yourself and check out the high street :-)
Winter stinks for vintage lovers, doesn't it?? Alas, I do commit the sin of black tights with a vintage dress. Because otherwise I wouldn't have an opportunity to wear said lovely dress except for a few months out of there year where I live. In the often bitterly cold, slush and dirty-snow filled big cities of the Midwest US, sometimes you have to sacrifice a bit of form for function. For me that's no actual vintage shoes (and not even my nicest repro shoes) unless the ground is dry, no bare or even thin stocking legs unless it warms up slightly. Otherwise a few minutes outside during the dead of winter and I could a) get frostbite or b) ruin my shoes. Though even doing that I have a really hard time finding footwear that I can wear in winter and feel okay about. Ugh.
ReplyDeleteSo sadly, whether I like it or not, I have to make some concessions where I live due to weather. Just no way to (comfortably and safely) get around it. :) THANK GOODNESS the weather is starting to turn a bit, and I'll be able to not freeze completely soon. Yay!
I really don't understand how women survived winter weather in the past. I hate being cold! As a college student, I walk a lot! So dresses and skirts are out of the picture all winter. :( I usually sink to a low of jeans, snow boots and sweatshirts. I have to wear modern with my vintage as my vintage wardrobe is still quite small. Fortunately, a lot of classic pieces were classics back in the day too!
ReplyDeleteI think most people need to have some modern in their wardrobe, even if it's only to combat weather that might ruin your vintage! So you might need to add some modern pieces back into your wardrobe. Just put as much care and thought into each purchase as you would a vintage garment and I'm sure you'll be able to slip some new pieces into your wardrobe.
Poor Jen, it is tough when you are committed to one particular period. I am lucky to be a bit of an era tart, I love them all so it is much easier to mix and match. Thank goodness for 70s knee high boots and chunky 50s cardis! Shoes in particular are a nightmare though, even deadstock is so delicate because the glue breaks down. I tend to save vintage shoes for best, because otherwise they just fall apart and that is so sad. And of course there is nothing wrong with buying new if you find something you love, it is just that us vintage girls get so addicted to the thrill of the vintage chase that we forget that new things can be nice sometimes too xx
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure I have that problem in Winter, here - stockings are generally warm enough for me and I actually find vintage coats, whilst definitely warmer, are too heavy for me, so I get lighter, not-so-warm, modern coats (which are still vintage-esque because the trench looking coat hasn't changed ALL that much...right?). But I do have that problem in summer. Sleep in curlers when it's been 40C all day? Hot weather, sometimes humid, just ruins my set. Sweating ruins my make-up and, as I only own nylon slips, and they're awful in summer. =[
ReplyDeleteHowever, I do concede, it's easier to fake it in summer - a pair of shorts, a light cotton blouse, sand shoes and a ponytail and, hey presto, a '50s look.
Anyway, despite my rambling, I mean to say: I feel your pain. I don't like buying a lot of new clothes, mainly for reasons around recycling, mass production, etc. Plus, they're never very good quality for what I can afford. And I'm also too lazy to see which brands are ethically made...So, I also browse charity shops from time to time.
Although, my ethics don't extend to footwear, unfortunately, and I often buy cheaply made (probably in a sweatshop) new shoes because I obviously need shoes but can't afford all vintage, right now. Woe.
Also, now that you're knitting, you can make yourself some lovely warm clothes for winter, too. Heh. =] I'm already knitting up scarves and what-not in preparation.
-Andi x
Adore those shoes!
ReplyDeleteI have a good amount of vintage coats I love but as far as winter vintage clothes I feel your pain.Its hard to look cute AND stay warm.
AWW!!! Those shoes are so 'Jean Harlow' Aww well this spring 2011 lots of designers are takjng a pludge on clasic shapes of the 50's so you might find something special in the shops! Its all up to you!! I love your vintage look!!
ReplyDeleteoh Jen I feel your pain. I have to say I used to be very period correct, wouldn't dream of wearing anything that wasn't, however I think as I've got older - a lot older! - and more practical in that I don't impose rules on myself as much I mix a bit more. I agree though I hate 'mixing' but I also hate being wet or cold.
ReplyDeleteI would say I don't have to compromise much but the snow this year has led me to total torment, I still don't have appropriate footwear, when it was really bad I was wearing 3 pairs of socks and wellies, hardly stylish!! I would rather wear wellies that unstylish boots, ridiculous huh?!!
I don't know what the answer is apart from wear what you feel happy in, I have that wanting to be correct thing in me big time still & I certainly wouldn't appear in 'public' so to speak not wearing what I want to but practical dress sometimes has to take priority.
I think it's time you started knitting more, this might help you stay warm :o)
Just a thought.... it has always been cold in Blightly, girls didnt just wear pretty cotton dressesin the 40s and 50s.
ReplyDeleteMy staple winter wardrobe is freddies jeams, wooly jumpers, and plaid jackets, none of which are vintage.. it doenst bother me, i dont want to be wearing vitnage whilst on country walks with a muddy dog! I like mixing summer/ spring dresses with my hunter wellies and thick chunky woolen socks, for a land girl look. As for tights i prefer, woolen grey, cream or burgandy.
I get anoyed at my chunky woolen scarf messes up my hair! does anyone else find this? if its down i end up with my curls turning to deadlocks or if its up the scard messes up the back >:(
And i dont think you are missing out on much not shopping on the high street, its rubbish!
On the bright side.... its getting warmer! I cannot wait til spring.. when its cardigan weather! :)
http://booboo-kitty-couture.blogspot.com/
Winter is horrid for vintage lovers! I can't help thinking that we have a bit of a warped perception of what our ancestors wore. It is no surprise that the bulk of vintage we see is "special" clothing and is lightweight. I bet you the things they wore everyday to function and keep warm in just wore out and was not considered nice enough to save and pass on.
ReplyDeleteWe rely heavily on pictures (expensive to take in those days) or movies (completely unrealistic) so I do think we have a over-romantic view looking back.
Also I think we are very used to choice, many dresses and outfits rather than just a few (or even only one) winter dresses.
I really hear you on the shoes in particular - please someone, invent a time machine before next winter!
Fab post :) I hear what you are saying. But - I am not a stalwart when it comes to vintage items. I like to look 40's - but I own hardly any actual vintage - and certainly no winter wear. I like to look as authentic as I can. Some days this lapses into "inspired" or "with a hint of vintage" - but thats the price I pay for practicality and warmth! :) Liking a landgirl look - I could get away with wellies and a headscarf in the snow :)
ReplyDeleteEnjoy the highstreet and charity shops for a while - and with the money you may have saved - you can splurge on something victoriously vintage when the finer weather hoves into view :)
Fortunately I have no qualms about authenticity so I've been keeping my legs warm with opaque tights in a variety of colours and prints all winter!
ReplyDeleteI like a certain look, but I achieve it mostly with a mish mash of charity shop finds, vintage and reproduction. I've spent most of the winter with my hair in pin curls under a beret as well!
My biggest problem really is being an utter tart about footwear. I have spent most of the winter with cold wet feet as I refuse to wear sensible flat waterproof shoes with deep treads, preferring instead to teeter round in heels all winter!
Bring on Spring I say!
I find myself stuck in a similar dilemma! I tend to think of myself as kind of an anti-purist, as vintage clothing is so difficult to find in the right size at the right price. At the same time I actually try to shop the high street, but more often than not fail to find anything fits right or is in a vintage style (plus everything is polyester and acrylic! Where's all the wool and cotton?!).
ReplyDeleteIn fact I've now resorted to learning to sew my own clothes using vintage patterns, so I guess I've come full circle and back around into purist territory!
But I'm not bothered about switching out the seamed stockings for tights - much as I like the romantic idea of living charmingly vintage in seamed stockings, tights are just more comfortable and practical.
Perhaps you should try the non-purist approach - as much joy as there is in recreating the styles of the past, it's actually kind of fun to put together a look that's wholly your own.
In the meantime, to the question of staying warm in winter... Wool cardigans (twinsets, even!) are the answer - hard to find 40s/50s vintage, though. And do check the charity shops for 80s wool skirts. If necessary they can be hemmed to 40s knee length quite easily, and they're cheap as chips, often decent quality, and warm! Or as someone else suggested, the land girl look is both authentic and warm.
Also, I'm so with you on wishing for the warmer weather to hurry up already!
xx Charlotte
Tuppence Ha'penny Vintage
Enjoy it while you can! What is adorable at 25, can look matronly at 45. I'm mixing more contemporary pieces in with my vintage and simplifying my look as I get older. Not so the purses and jewelery, though ;-D
ReplyDeleteWhy don't you British girls find some snuggies to wear under your winter skirts? Sort of the downstairs version of a vest, fine knit bicycle short type garment, Would be so cute to wear over a suspender belt... Hanro or John Smedley was still making them within the last 5 years, but we have had to special order them in the States.
Thank you ladies for your incredible comments and suggestions. It seems the Land Girl look is very popular in the winter months! Don't get me wrong, when I'm popping to the shops or having a relaxing weekend, I like nothing better than putting on my Freddies dungarees and saddle shoes, but its the other 5 days of the week when I'm at work that are a pain!! x
ReplyDeleteIn that case I would say Deborah above has the right suggestion. Thermals are the way to go, you can get some seriously cute ones and noone will ever know.....
ReplyDeleteI'm also with the Baroness on wearing wellies through the snow/rain and changing shoes once you get to your destination. I would be hearbroken if I ruined a lovely pair of shoes.
Oh and to elaborate, I didn't mean to be flippant just saying 'checkout the high street'. There are little gems to be found but you do have to hunt them down! I love to shop so much that doesn't bother me in the least but I know everyone does not have the same shop-til-you-drop mentality as me.
I agree about the thermal underwear, it's perfect for covering the gap between your regular knickers and stockings. And if it's too warm to wear indoors, it's easy to just take it off, not like tights. If you want to be more authentic about it, I'm sure you could find an old knitting pattern to make your own, there's plenty of time before next winter :)
ReplyDeleteMy goodness, I lóve those snakeskin shoes.
ReplyDeleteI think I see green of envy!
I'm not so dedicated to my vintage look in the winter. I live in Winnipeg, Canada and the temperature can drop to -50 degrees Celcius in the winter here! Bundling up is sometimes a necessity!!
ReplyDeleteI long for summer when I can enjoy my vintage without tights, socks and boots all layered together.
Oh God, I was reading this and it sounds exactly like my problems. I love vintage clothes and I sew my own vintage inspired wardrobe. For a long time I have been trying to figure out what did women in the 50s wear when it was -10 degrees and snow, and came to the conclusion that they just didn't go outside during that weather. Cursed by frequent urinary infections, every time it's cold and snowy, I ditch my style for a day or two and wear warm black tights, a wool skirt and warm boots.
ReplyDeleteLove, love, love your blog.... I admire you for abandoning the modern threads in favor of all vintage, I really wish I could do that, but I can only collect a few accessories here and there. I think my most prized is a brooch from my great-great-grandmother (which I have pinned to everything from a clutch to a coat and a dress). Hopefully your weather is warming up so you can eliminate the layers and let your clothes shine. :)
ReplyDeletehttp://www.nostalgiclibrarian.blogspot.com
I find that on days when i dont want to be so aware of my clothing getting, wet stained or caught on something its so nice to have a backup wardrobe you can relax in but still feel stylish.
ReplyDeleteMy hayday trousers have got me through many an afternoon. Also I found in Topshop last christmas, (a lot of it went into the sale) some amazing 1930s/20s patterned dresses, convincingly bias cut and made from much more sensible fabric. Expensive before they went into the sale they ended up being quite reasonable.
Its so nice to be a little less careful with pieces but then again you always run the risk of seeing someone else in the same thing.
And lets face it, vintage is always an investment... The excuse i always tell myself when i fork out money i dont really have on a dress i dont really need!
P.S - I have those exact snakeskin shoes. Rather a favourite of mine they are looking a little worse for wear after an evening out the other week.
ReplyDeleteI think it would be interesting to do some research into what ladies wore during the winter 'back then' :)
ReplyDeleteA quick look suggests thicker dresses, LONG wool and/or fur coats and boots if it was snowy.
ReplyDeleteI think the thermal undies sounds good ;)
Oh and trouser suits. Some wintry photos show the ladies wearing trousers under their dresses while outside!
ReplyDelete